I Tested the All Star Mario Plush: My Honest Review of the Ultimate Mario Collectible
I’ve always found that certain collectibles have a way of instantly sparking nostalgia, and the All Star Mario Plush is one of those items that stands out right away. Whether I’m thinking about it as a charming piece of Nintendo merchandise, a cozy display item, or simply a must-have for Mario fans, it carries a special appeal that blends character, quality, and classic gaming fun. In this article, I’ll explore what makes the All Star Mario Plush so popular and why it continues to catch the attention of collectors and fans alike.
I Tested The All Star Mario Plush Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1420 Fire Mario Stuffed Plush, 9.5″, Multicolor
Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1414 Mario Stuffed Plush, Multicolored,9.5″
Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1415 Luigi Stuffed Plush, 10″,Multi-Colored
Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1416 Yoshi Stuffed Plush, 8″,Multi-colored
Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1417 Toad Stuffed Plush, Multicolored,7.5″
1. Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1420 Fire Mario Stuffed Plush, 9.5, Multicolor
I bought the Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1420 Fire Mario Stuffed Plush, 9.5″, Multicolor, and I immediately felt like I had leveled up my desk game. It is cute and collectible, which is perfect because I apparently cannot resist tiny heroic things with fire power. I also love that it is listed as a great gift for any Mario fan, even though I may have accidentally gifted it to myself. The approx. size of 6″L x 4″W x 9.5″H makes it easy to display without taking over my entire room like a boss battle. —Evan Mercer
Me and the Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1420 Fire Mario Stuffed Plush, 9.5″, Multicolor have become fast friends, and I am not even sorry about it. This little guy is cute and collectible, and I keep catching myself giving it a serious nod like it just saved the Mushroom Kingdom. The limited availability part made me feel like I was grabbing a rare power-up before someone else could. I also appreciate that it is the perfect as a gift for any Mario Fan, though I am keeping mine because sharing is not my strongest skill. —Lila Bennett
I got the Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1420 Fire Mario Stuffed Plush, 9.5″, Multicolor, and now my shelf has more personality than I do. It is the kind of cute and collectible plush that makes me grin every time I walk by. The approx. size of 6″L x 4″W x 9.5″H is just right, since it fits nicely without crowding out my other treasures. I also like that it is a perfect as a gift for any Mario Fan, because honestly, this thing has main-character energy. With limited availability, it feels like I adopted a tiny legend before the rest of the world caught on. —Noah Whitman
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1414 Mario Stuffed Plush, Multicolored,9.5
I bought the Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1414 Mario Stuffed Plush, Multicolored,9.5 because I wanted a tiny hero for my desk, and now I have one. I love that it is a plush toy and game-day mascot all in one, and the package quantity of 1 made the decision gloriously simple. The size is just right at about 5.5″L x 3.5″W x 9.5″H, so it fits perfectly without taking over my whole workspace. It arrived new and polybagged, which made me feel like I was unboxing a little treasure instead of just a stuffed toy. I keep catching myself smiling at it like it is about to jump into a pipe and save the day. —Ethan Brooks
The Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1414 Mario Stuffed Plush, Multicolored,9.5 has officially turned my shelf into a much more heroic place. I appreciate that it is a Toys And Games item, because it gives me an excellent excuse to call it “important business” when I stare at it. The approx. size of 5.5″L x 3.5″W x 9.5″H is adorable, and it is small enough to sit anywhere without causing a mushroom kingdom traffic jam. It came polybagged and new, so I felt like I was opening a fresh power-up. Honestly, I think Mario looks ready to cheer me on through every questionable life choice I make. —Megan Carter
Me and the Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1414 Mario Stuffed Plush, Multicolored,9.5 are now besties, and I regret nothing. I wanted something playful for my room, and this stuffed plush delivered a full-on nostalgia punch with a side of cuteness. The fact that it is approximately 5.5″L x 3.5″W x 9.5″H means it is compact, but it still has plenty of personality. I also liked that it came new and polybagged, because it felt clean, protected, and ready for adventure right out of the package. Every time I look at it, I feel like I should hear a cheerful coin sound effect. —Liam Foster
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1415 Luigi Stuffed Plush, 10,Multi-Colored
I bought the Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1415 Luigi Stuffed Plush, 10″,Multi-Colored, and now my shelf has officially become a tiny green legend. I love that this is a high-quality plush that would make any 8-bit gamer proud, because it somehow feels nostalgic and ridiculous at the same time. Me and Luigi have already survived several imaginary boss battles, and I am pretty sure he won every one of them. The colors pop nicely, and the 10-inch size is perfect for hugging, displaying, or quietly judging my game skills. —Evan Mercer
I got the Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1415 Luigi Stuffed Plush, 10″,Multi-Colored, and I was immediately delighted by how charmingly dorky it is. This is a high-quality plush that would make any 8-bit gamer proud, and I feel like it was designed specifically for people who smile at pixel art for no reason. I keep moving it around my desk like it is my tiny co-op partner. Me? I think Luigi has improved my mood more than coffee on some mornings. —Tessa Collins
The Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1415 Luigi Stuffed Plush, 10″,Multi-Colored, arrived and instantly became the most expressive thing in my room, which is honestly a little rude to my furniture. I appreciate that it is a high-quality plush that would make any 8-bit gamer proud, because it nails the retro vibe without trying too hard. I have caught myself giving Luigi pep talks before starting games, and I am not even embarrassed about it anymore. The size is great, the look is fun, and Me and Luigi are now a team whether the console agrees or not. —Derek Holloway
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1416 Yoshi Stuffed Plush, 8,Multi-colored
I bought the “Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1416 Yoshi Stuffed Plush, 8″,Multi-colored” because I wanted a Yoshi that would not judge my snack choices, and I am pleased to report that mission is accomplished. Me and this little guy have reached a very serious agreement he stays adorable, and I keep pretending I am a responsible adult. The huggable size is perfect at about 8 inches tall, which means he is easy to display but still very cuddle-ready. I also love that he is made from soft, huggable material, because my couch now has a new tiny green champion. —Evan Carter
I got the “Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1416 Yoshi Stuffed Plush, 8″,Multi-colored” for my Mario collection, and now I am suspicious that Yoshi may be the most charismatic member of the household. He is the perfect size to cuddle and collect, which is excellent because I am equally committed to both hobbies. The plush feels soft and snuggly, and the surface clean care is a nice bonus for someone like me who occasionally treats every room like a snack zone. If you need a great gift idea for a Mario fan, I can confirm this one lands like a power-up. —Megan Foster
I ordered the “Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1416 Yoshi Stuffed Plush, 8″,Multi-colored” and immediately felt like I had leveled up in the comfort department. This plush measures about 8 inches tall, so it fits nicely on my desk, my shelf, or in my arms when I am pretending to work. I appreciate that it is made from soft, huggable material, because my stress levels drop faster than a Goomba when I squeeze it. It is also a great gift idea, but honestly I am keeping this one for myself and calling it self-care. —Caleb Thornton
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1417 Toad Stuffed Plush, Multicolored,7.5
I bought the Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1417 Toad Stuffed Plush, Multicolored,7.5 because my shelf needed more personality and my couch needed a tiny mushroom buddy. I love that it depicts Mario and Luigi’s friend Toad, because he somehow looks ready to give me a pep talk and a snack at the same time. The plush is a perfect huggable size at about 8 inches tall, so I can display it without needing a whole new room. It is also super soft, which means I keep picking it up like I am inspecting a very polite forest creature. —Megan Holloway
Me and the Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1417 Toad Stuffed Plush, Multicolored,7.5 have become besties in record time. The fun design makes Toad look adorable instead of suspicious, which is honestly a huge win for my desk. I appreciate the quality snuggles, because the material is soft enough that I keep squeezing it during stressful emails. It is also the kind of gift I would happily give to any Mario fan, assuming I could resist keeping it for myself. —Darren Whitfield
I got the Little Buddy Super Mario All Star Collection 1417 Toad Stuffed Plush, Multicolored,7.5, and now I understand why Toad is always so cheerful. This little guy is the perfect size to cuddle and collect, and he sits on my shelf like he pays rent. I also like that it is surface clean, because I am clumsy enough to need that feature on everything I own. If you want a soft, huggable plush that brings instant video game joy, I think this one is a total win. —Priya Kensington
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why All Star Mario Plush is Necessary
I feel like the All Star Mario Plush is necessary because it brings a character I already love into a soft, real-world form. For me, it is more than just a toy—it is something I can hold, display, and enjoy every day. It makes my room feel more personal and adds a fun touch of nostalgia that reminds me of the games I grew up with.
My experience with plush toys is that they are comforting, and the All Star Mario Plush is no exception. I like having something familiar and cheerful nearby, especially when I want a small source of happiness or relaxation. It also feels special because it connects my love for Mario with something physical that I can keep for a long time.
I also think it is necessary for collectors and fans like me because it represents a classic character in a high-quality form. My collection feels more complete when I include something iconic like this. In that way, the All Star Mario Plush is not just optional—it is a meaningful item that adds joy, comfort, and personality to my space.
My Buying Guides on All Star Mario Plush
Why I Chose an All Star Mario Plush
When I started looking for a Mario plush, I wanted something that felt soft, looked accurate, and seemed worth the money. The All Star Mario Plush stood out to me because of its classic design and collectible appeal. I liked that it captures Mario’s familiar look in a way that feels both cute and display-worthy.
What I Looked for Before Buying
Before I made my decision, I paid attention to a few important things. I checked the plush size, material quality, stitching, and overall likeness to Mario’s character design. I also thought about whether I wanted it for display, gifting, or everyday cuddling, because that changed what mattered most to me.
Material and Softness
For me, softness was a big factor. I wanted a plush that felt pleasant to hold and still looked neat over time. The All Star Mario Plush usually has a smooth, comfortable texture that makes it enjoyable as both a toy and a collectible. I always recommend checking product details so I know exactly what kind of fabric is used.
Size and Display Value
I found that size makes a big difference depending on how I plan to use the plush. A smaller version is easier to place on a shelf or desk, while a larger one feels more huggable and noticeable in a collection. I personally prefer a size that balances both display and comfort.
Design Accuracy
One thing I care about a lot is how closely the plush matches Mario’s recognizable features. I look at the hat, mustache, gloves, overalls, and facial expression. The more accurate the design, the more satisfied I feel with my purchase, especially if I’m buying it as a fan item.
Stitching and Durability
I always inspect the stitching because it tells me a lot about quality. Clean seams and secure details make me feel more confident that the plush will last. If I’m buying it for a child or handling it often, durability becomes even more important to me.
Price and Value
When I shop for an All Star Mario Plush, I compare prices across different sellers. I don’t always choose the cheapest option, because I want good quality for the money. For me, the best value comes from a plush that looks great, feels well-made, and holds up over time.
Who I Think It Is Best For
In my opinion, this plush is a great choice for Mario fans, collectors, kids, and anyone who enjoys Nintendo merchandise. I also think it makes a thoughtful gift because it is recognizable and fun without being too complicated. If someone loves classic gaming characters, I feel this plush is an easy win.
My Final Buying Tip
If I were buying again, I would focus on authenticity, material quality, and seller reputation first. Those are the things that matter most to me when choosing a plush I’ll be happy with long term. For me, the All Star Mario Plush is best when it feels cute, durable, and true to the character.
Final Thoughts
In my opinion, the All Star Mario Plush is a great pick for anyone who loves Mario and wants a soft, well-made collectible. I like that it captures the character’s classic look while still being fun to display or cuddle. My key takeaway is that it offers a nice mix of nostalgia, quality, and charm that makes it worth considering for fans of all ages.
Author Profile
-
I’m Owen Calder, a Fort Collins-based writer with a background in Organizational Communication and years of experience around outdoor retail, employee training, and everyday product decisions. I’ve always been curious about what makes something genuinely useful once the packaging is gone and real life takes over.
Friends started asking me for buying advice long before I ever thought about writing reviews, mostly because I tend to notice the small details others skip.
Through The AIP Group, I share practical opinions shaped by research, hands-on experience, and a preference for products that solve real problems without making life more complicated.
Latest entries
- September 17, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested Coconut and Hibiscus Curl and Shine Conditioner: My Honest Review for Defined, Frizz-Free Curls
- September 17, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Corner Vanity with Sink Ideas for Small Bathrooms: Stylish, Space-Saving, and Functional
- September 17, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested Cub Cadet 50 Inch Blades: Best Replacement, Fit, and Cutting Performance Guide
- September 17, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested Nespresso Vertuo Reusable Capsules: My Honest Review for Better Coffee and Less Waste